 |
|
|
Thursday, July 29, 2010
|
 | |  |
|
|
Pointing Lab Forums
|
 |
|
New Guy...Best PL Breeders...??
Last Post 04 Mar 2010 02:32 PM by Socks. 65 Replies.
|
Sort:
|
|
Prev Next |
You are not authorized to post a reply. |
|
Paco
 Advanced Member
 Posts:543
 On a trout stream in NW,MI.
 |
| 09 Feb 2010 05:19 PM |
|
Posted By chrissmith1313 on 08 Feb 2010 03:53 PM
I agree with others on this forum that said don't pick the kennel. Pick the parents. Wacth both the parents work and hunt. Watch pups of those two parents work and hunt would even be better. There are many good litters out there these days in all price ranges. You are doing the right thing by completing your research in advance so you can make an "informed decision". Good luck with your research!
Gotta agree with that Chris! (I like Ice)
Just very hard to do for some,but definitely the way to go if you can. |
|
_____________________________________________ Founding member- The Michigan Mafia (aka MM) :)
(and hopefully instilling a sense of humor)
-www.gforceretrievers.com-
3.5x GMPR HRCH Fraquelli's Sauble River "Gator"
CPR HRKs Liberators Outlaw "Rondo" CPR VeraGators Smokin' Diablo of G'Force "Smokey"
------------->" Let 'Em Roll ! "<-------------
|
|
|
micahd
 New Member
 Posts:95
 Preston Idaho
 |
| 09 Feb 2010 06:24 PM |
|
First of all welcome! You have found a resource of people and a wealth of information on here to help on your journey into the Pointing Lab world. I do have a couple of recommendations for you as well. Attend an APLA event and also look into the HRC events and the AKC hunt tests and Field Trials. The APLA events dont take place quite as frequently as the others do. Also look at gunclub labradors and order Julies book, Training the Pointing Labrador. There is a difference in how you train a pointing lab versus a flushing lab and this will help. My next point is HUGE. go to kennels, breeders etc and look at parents only. You will find out soon enough that Labradors do not make ugly puppies. Dont even go look at a litter unless its one you would consider buying from. Otherwise that emotion and the eagerness to get started on a Dog will kick in. Most of all have fun and ask all the questions on here you can. Good Luck!! |
|
|
|
|
TomCat
 New Member
 Posts:5 Two Harbors, MN
 |
| 09 Feb 2010 09:17 PM |
|
Posted By micahd on 09 Feb 2010 06:24 PM First of all welcome! You have found a resource of people and a wealth of information on here to help on your journey into the Pointing Lab world. I do have a couple of recommendations for you as well. Attend an APLA event and also look into the HRC events and the AKC hunt tests and Field Trials. The APLA events dont take place quite as frequently as the others do. Also look at gunclub labradors and order Julies book, Training the Pointing Labrador. There is a difference in how you train a pointing lab versus a flushing lab and this will help. My next point is HUGE. go to kennels, breeders etc and look at parents only. You will find out soon enough that Labradors do not make ugly puppies. Dont even go look at a litter unless its one you would consider buying from. Otherwise that emotion and the eagerness to get started on a Dog will kick in. Most of all have fun and ask all the questions on here you can. Good Luck!!
Well stated I hope to visit a couple of kennels this week and promise NOT to look at puppies. Also discovered that my neighbor is AKC Field Trial judge and on Board of local retriever club. His advice..."watch the "bitches" the males all seem quite good but much of the time the females are the weak link...hold out for strong pedigrees on both sides of the litter." I have to admit that after he said that I have noticed that often the female is the weak link in the genetics of the litter. Thanks...TomCat...also looking at the South Dakota hunt test in May... |
|
|
|
|
JoeMac
 New Member
 Posts:13
 |
| 24 Feb 2010 11:14 AM |
|
Go to the source.....and they're close: Cashman's |
|
|
|
|
OD
 Basic Member
 Posts:176
 |
| 24 Feb 2010 03:22 PM |
|
I have to agree. The fermales are almost always the weak link. They are also the ones that will have th greatest infl;ucne on the genetics. If both side look good your heade in the right direction.
I have written an article on this very subject with a fair amount of detail that can be read on my web site under how to pick a pup. www.poudrerivergundogs.com
Unfortunately their are still many people breeding CP and JH dogs. Better than no titles but why not look at 4XGMPR , MH, HRCH females? One reason their are very few of them. It requires an investment and those looking to make a buck will never do that. Many people are looking for a few bucks with a litter of pups from CP's . Personally I think for folks looking for good dogs it is a mistake to not expect more. It is also a disservice to the breed. Not everyone is looking to produce a better dog. That is the only reasons to produce a litter of pups in my opinion. My opinion anyway.
Gary |
|
|
|
|
hooligan
 Veteran Member
 Posts:1054
 Pac NW
 |
| 24 Feb 2010 05:30 PM |
|
Posted By OD on 24 Feb 2010 03:22 PM
The fermales are almost always the weak link. They are also the ones that will have th greatest infl;ucne on the genetics.
This is just not true. Genes come 50% from the male and 50% from the female-neither has a greater influence than the other.
Many females are less titled-but often not because of less ability. They aren't campaigned as hard-because they come into heat and people want to breed pups. They spend lots more time with the pups than the sires do-often the sires never see their pups. If pups and dams are together in the field-who knows how much the pups learn from their moms? I know people who believe hunting a pregnant bitch has a positive influence on the pups. Sires produce lots of pups-some are great, some are not. Very, very few sires produce noteworthy pups regardless of who they are bred to. Dams, though, can produce litters with notably good dogs in each-even when they are bred to a different sire each time. In the cutting horse world, a great deal of importance is placed on the dam's lineage, quality and her ability. Foals from a dam who is herself a winner are more valued than those from a dam who is not. I think there would be an increase in the quality and abilities of PL pups if more people trained and showed their bitches to higher levels-and only bred the really good ones based on performance instead of what's on paper.
|
|
| An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. |
|
|
Paco
 Advanced Member
 Posts:543
 On a trout stream in NW,MI.
 |
| 24 Feb 2010 05:55 PM |
|
Nice post HOOLI,,,,,,,,,,,,
Gary,
I realize this guy is searching for the best kennels that breed etc..
At first glance I tend to agree with some of what you are saying.................and I do!!! SOME.
Hooligan handled the female stuff,soooooo.
--------------------------------------------------
! ! ! Not everyone that happens to have a dog that really can up the ante in the gene pool,,,hunt tests,cares about titles,has the money or means even if they want to,,,etc.etc.etc.
I happen to fall into one or more of those categories,and there are more,,,are my dogs less talented, because I like to have some money left at fall hunting time,so choose not to campaign him/her/them much? It's about talent(sound healthy talent).
-------------
----SOMETHING TO PONDER???
Are ONLY those with money and means to title,test, and campaign their dogs the ones with the most talented dogs? That should be bred?,,,,,I wonder.
.............This brings up something else I have observed,there are a bunch of highly titled dogs I would not rate highly,and have real doubts about at the real deal(Waterfowl hunting,and upland hunting on wild birds,or preserve for that matter),but realize this falls under personal taste a bit,so maybe not worth two cents..
Lots of dogs with high titles out there,Joe Hunter with that dog next to him on the couch might be more than most could imagine,,,JUST MORE TO THINK ABOUT.
What it gets back to is do your homework,as stated more than a few times here.When I'm checkin' out the dogs,I look for those that WOW me,,,,and a few do. |
|
_____________________________________________ Founding member- The Michigan Mafia (aka MM) :)
(and hopefully instilling a sense of humor)
-www.gforceretrievers.com-
3.5x GMPR HRCH Fraquelli's Sauble River "Gator"
CPR HRKs Liberators Outlaw "Rondo" CPR VeraGators Smokin' Diablo of G'Force "Smokey"
------------->" Let 'Em Roll ! "<-------------
|
|
|
hooligan
 Veteran Member
 Posts:1054
 Pac NW
 |
| 24 Feb 2010 06:40 PM |
|
Titles. A good thing, and a bad thing. Good, because a dog has to have a certain level of ability to pass a test-the higher the test, the better skills the dog must possess if it is going to be able to pass. Bad, because dogs can be trained to pass-I am talking about the pointing stuff in this instance. For the retriever stuff, a dog has to have some ability-if a dog can't remember a triple, then it can't. But a dog can be trained to stop and freeze on scent. If you've seen it, you can tell-but it will pass the test because that's what's required. I'm a perfect example. I have a nice dog. He's my buddy, and I like having him around, and he's an amazing hunting dog and I'm happy with him. We train to the best of MY ability-and we go to tests when it's convenient and I'm ready. He should have big titles. If I would send him to a trainer, he'd have them. But you know what? He'd still be the same dog he is now...he'd just have more initials. |
|
| An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. |
|
|
OD
 Basic Member
 Posts:176
 |
| 24 Feb 2010 06:53 PM |
|
Hooligan. Cant change DNA strands. But I have a significant amount of empirical data that proves my point about females. 100's of puppies. When I say genetics I'm talking about specific traits that the female has that will express itself in the offspring. Dominant in pups. Semantics I guess? It is interesting you have stated pretty much the same thing with some evidence in your post as well? " Very, very few sires produce noteworthy pups regardless of who they are bred to. Dams, though, can produce litters with notably good dogs in each-even when they are bred to a different sire each time" . If the genetic influence was 50 /50 that would be impossible. Horses, dogs, very similar. That is also why I would argue the point with anyone females for the most part have the biggest influence. The evidence is overwhelming. I have seen Sires that consistently produce good litters. Few but they are out there. Most are not the ones you hear about in advertising or have been bred the most. You will find them from the people that are breeding to produce a better dog and not driven by profit. One of the best dogs I have ever worked with is hunted only. How can you know your dogs ability if it is not developed and tested? My standards are probably not the same as some others because of what I do on a daily basis. Everyone decides what is important to them. As a person I know use to hunt lions with his hounds said " you feed the dog do what you want" . Everyone has and opinion of what a good dog is based on their needs and experience. Which is the way it should be? Good luck to the guy who started this thread. Be patient and do your homework. The pay off could be worth the effort. Gary |
|
|
|
|
hooligan
 Veteran Member
 Posts:1054
 Pac NW
 |
| 24 Feb 2010 07:21 PM |
|
OD, I think a lot of the "dam's influence" is environmental-it's what she passes on to her pups-or foals-while she is with them. I think we agree-just different words? |
|
| An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. |
|
|
rames14
 New Member
 Posts:21
 |
| 25 Feb 2010 05:19 AM |
|
A lot of good information here. I was in the same boat (sorta' still am). I lost my hunting buddy almost exactly two years ago. I started by going to an APLA event in Minnesota. Met a lot of great people and got some leads. That lead to one of Julie Knutson's seminars, where I met some of the same people and others (including Hooligan). That lead me to a specific dog in a specific kennel. I went to Larkspur Colorado and watched the female that I identified run and receiver her GMPR. She is now a 4x GMPR. The stud is being carefully selected and will be chosen in the next week probably, with the breeding taking place shortly (I hope). This has been a two year investigation. I have been involved every step of the way and discussed the specific traits that were being bred as well as the genetic health - EIC, CNM, OFA, CERF, etc. I know that the dogs being bred will be tested for all known issues as well as either titled or soon to be titled. And the pedigrees have been studied closely. Homework, homework, homework. Good luck. I am hoping to have my pup early summer and to be seen in the field this fall with a gangling puppy learning about birds. |
|
|
|
|
Paco
 Advanced Member
 Posts:543
 On a trout stream in NW,MI.
 |
| 25 Feb 2010 07:53 AM |
|
Posted By OD on 24 Feb 2010 06:53 PM
I have seen Sires that consistently produce good litters. Few but they are out there. Most are not the ones you hear about in advertising or have been bred the most. You will find them from the people that are breeding to produce a better dog and not driven by profit. AGREE,,,but,probably naively,I WOULD HOPE THAT THE ONES BEING BRED THE MOST ARE THE CREAM OF THE CROP,the high budget marketing and upper price range pups the best of the best????? One of the best dogs I have ever worked with is hunted only. How can you know your dogs ability if it is not developed and tested? Gary
Testing is a viable way to check out talent,,,,actually checking out the sire and dam(and their offspring)hunting is better,but hard for buyers to do....lets go hunt them... |
|
_____________________________________________ Founding member- The Michigan Mafia (aka MM) :)
(and hopefully instilling a sense of humor)
-www.gforceretrievers.com-
3.5x GMPR HRCH Fraquelli's Sauble River "Gator"
CPR HRKs Liberators Outlaw "Rondo" CPR VeraGators Smokin' Diablo of G'Force "Smokey"
------------->" Let 'Em Roll ! "<-------------
|
|
|
Top Dog Kennels
 Advanced Member
 Posts:535 South Dakota
 |
| 25 Feb 2010 08:51 AM |
|
|
|
| "Gettin' Straight To the Point" |
|
|
keskam
 Veteran Member
 Posts:1339
 Pierce, Colorado
 |
| 25 Feb 2010 02:09 PM |
|
So if the female passes most of the genetics then the pups should be sold for a couple grand and the 4x gmpr stud fee should only be around 300.  instead of 1200 to 1500 |
|
HRCH Rocky Mountain Rosco SH APR HR Lady Satin of Black Forest JH HRCH Satin's Jumpin Jedi JH HR Chelsea Snow Angel JH GMPR HR KB's Snakey Jake of Poudre River JH APR HR KB's It's Showtime of Bearpoint (Star) JH HR KB's Loaded To Go Allie JH SHR KB's Blazin' White Thunder (Blaze) KB'S Misty's Mighty Trooper Dusty
|
|
|
gum
 New Member
 Posts:17
 |
| 25 Feb 2010 04:53 PM |
|
This is something I heard a long time ago from my mentor who still trains weekly with me. He has produced 2 FCs and been in the game over 50 years and is still throwing birds at 74. I think it is kinda cute. Your field trial dogs are your pro baseball players and your hunt test dogs are your AA players and your hunting dogs are your beer league softball players. It takes a pretty poor dog to not be a good hunting dog. That is why we have tests because there is a big swing of the pendulum from what one person thinks is a good hunting dog and what the other guy thinks. Just food for thought. |
|
|
|
|
gum
 New Member
 Posts:17
 |
| 25 Feb 2010 05:10 PM |
|
He also said if your happy with your dog that's all that counts. So you should get the best dog you can afford. |
|
|
|
|
Paco
 Advanced Member
 Posts:543
 On a trout stream in NW,MI.
 |
| 25 Feb 2010 06:55 PM |
|
Posted By gum on 25 Feb 2010 04:53 PM
This is something I heard a long time ago from my mentor who still trains weekly with me. He has produced 2 FCs and been in the game over 50 years and is still throwing birds at 74. I think it is kinda cute. Your field trial dogs are your pro baseball players and your hunt test dogs are your AA players and your hunting dogs are your beer league softball players. It takes a pretty poor dog to not be a good hunting dog. That is why we have tests because there is a big swing of the pendulum from what one person thinks is a good hunting dog and what the other guy thinks. Just food for thought.
Had a long reply to that,,,,lost it.Will just say the line---" It takes a pretty poor dog to not be a good hunting dog"--- is way off.
Bring up your highest titled,and we'll go hunt some grouse,I'll run my 10 mth old hardly started to train,may never test dog....
Have seen a bunch of titled dogs that had no clue when they finally got a taste of the real deal.
Have also seen some of what are likely some of the best..AFTER BRINGING OUT THE INNATE ABILITIES,TRAINING,TESTING (if you choose to.. It takes exposure/hunting them,the more the better......Cheers.......................
(ps: Be aware that smilies would be at appropriate places,but they too don't seem to work,like posting pictures,you have to have a secret combo)...LOL |
|
_____________________________________________ Founding member- The Michigan Mafia (aka MM) :)
(and hopefully instilling a sense of humor)
-www.gforceretrievers.com-
3.5x GMPR HRCH Fraquelli's Sauble River "Gator"
CPR HRKs Liberators Outlaw "Rondo" CPR VeraGators Smokin' Diablo of G'Force "Smokey"
------------->" Let 'Em Roll ! "<-------------
|
|
|
gum
 New Member
 Posts:17
 |
| 25 Feb 2010 08:19 PM |
|
Paco, hey if your happy with your dog that's all that matters, thanks for the invite but I will stay in SD and hunt.I think I hunt real deal. PS any dog can run all over a field. |
|
|
|
|
jschierholz
 New Member
 Posts:52
 Hartley,IA 51346
 |
| 25 Feb 2010 08:24 PM |
|
Mr gum......newbie here......but your tiled dogs would be????????????? |
|
| CPR TDK's Sauk Dakota Juiced Thunder n Lightning Thor "Thor" //
CPR Prairie Pts Jameson Rocks Waterman Creek "Jimmy" //
TDK's Blue Hunter Rose Lady Jasmine "Jaz"
|
|
|
Top Dog Kennels
 Advanced Member
 Posts:535 South Dakota
 |
| 25 Feb 2010 08:31 PM |
|
|
|
| "Gettin' Straight To the Point" |
|
|
| You are not authorized to post a reply. |
|
Active Forums 4.1
|
|
|
|
|
 | |  |
|
|
|
 |